Skip to content

Which one to choose in Mexico

Isla Contoy vs Holbox

Two islands in Mexico. Isla Contoy has 10 tours to book; Holbox has 95 tours to book. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Isla Contoy

Isla Contoy

Mexico

Isla Contoy is a protected bird island in the Caribbean about 30 kilometres north of Isla Mujeres, only 8.5 kilometres long and closed to everyone except a limited number of day visitors on licensed boats. It is the wildest beach within reach of Cancun, with nesting frigatebirds, pelicans and turtles and no hotels or roads.

Read the full guide →

Holbox

Holbox

Mexico

Holbox is a narrow, car-free island about 42 km long off the north coast of the Yucatan Peninsula, separated from the mainland by a shallow lagoon full of flamingos and pelicans. Sand streets, golf carts, painted murals and whale sharks offshore in summer make it Mexico's quiet alternative to Cancun.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

Isla ContoyHolbox
Gateway & travel time1 to 2 h by boat from Cancun or Isla Mujeres25 min by ferry; 3 to 3.5 h in total from Cancun from Chiquila (ferry); transfers from Cancun
DaysA day trip is enough3 to 5 nights
Best monthsDec–Apr dry and calm; Jun–Nov hurricane season; boats cancelled in rough seasJun–Sep whale sharks, hot; Nov–Apr dry, windy; Sep–Oct stormy
CarOn foot only, on short marked trails and the beach next to the landingCar-free: walk, cycle or hire a golf cart; golf-cart taxis on sand streets
CostMid-range for the Mexican Caribbean; park fee often includedMid-range; pricier than the mainland, cash often needed
BeachesA long, quiet white beach by the landing; swimming only in the marked areaPale sand and shallow, greenish water; Punta Cocos and Punta Mosquito sandbars
Area3.2 km²56 km²
PopulationUninhabited1,841 (2020)
Highest point3 m1 m
Tours online1095

Where they are

Tours and activities in Mexico