Skip to content

Which one to choose in Inner Hebrides

Islay vs Isle of Mull

Two islands in Inner Hebrides. Islay has 7 tours to book; Isle of Mull has 8 tours to book. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Islay

Islay

Inner Hebrides, United Kingdom

Islay is the southernmost island of the Inner Hebrides, about 620 square kilometres of peat moor, sandy bays and farmland, and the most famous whisky island in the world. Its distilleries make the smoky malts known everywhere, while winter geese, Atlantic beaches and early Christian crosses give non-drinkers plenty to do.

Read the full guide →

Isle of Mull

Isle of Mull

Inner Hebrides, United Kingdom

Mull is the second-largest island of the Inner Hebrides, a 45-minute ferry crossing from Oban on the west coast of Scotland. It has the colourful harbour of Tobermory, the Munro of Ben More, white-tailed eagles, otters and puffins, and it is the stepping stone to Iona and Staffa.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

IslayIsle of Mull
Gateway & travel timeAbout 2 h by ferry or 40 min by air from Kennacraig ferry terminal; flights from Glasgow45 min by ferry from Oban (ferry to Craignure)
Days3 to 5 nights3 to 5 nights
Best monthsMay–Sep; whisky festival in late May; geese Oct–AprMay–Sep; puffins on Staffa and Lunga May–Jul; midges in high summer
CarA car is best; limited buses link the villages; taxis needed after tastingsA car is best; buses link Craignure with Tobermory and Fionnphort; single-track roads
CostMid-range for Scotland; tastings add upMid-range for Scotland; limited rooms push summer prices up
BeachesLong empty strands: Machir Bay, Saligo, Laggan Bay and the Singing Sands near Port EllenWhite shell sand at Calgary Bay and near Fionnphort; cold, clear water and few people
Area620 km²875 km²
Population3,228 (2011)2,800 (2011)
Highest point491 m (Beinn Bheigeir)966 m (Ben More)
Tours online78

Where they are

Tours and activities in Inner Hebrides