Skip to content

Which one to choose in Italy

Isola Comacina vs Isola San Giulio

Two islands in Italy. Isola Comacina has 1 tour to book; Isola San Giulio has 21 tours to book. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Isola Comacina

Isola Comacina

Italy

Isola Comacina is the only island in Lake Como, a wooded strip about 600 metres long lying a few hundred metres off the western shore near Sala Comacina and Ossuccio. It is uninhabited today, but scattered with the ruins of medieval churches, and makes a short, peaceful stop between the lake's villas and villages.

Read the full guide →

Isola San Giulio

Isola San Giulio

Italy

Isola San Giulio is a tiny island in Lake Orta in Piedmont, northern Italy, only about 275 metres long and a few minutes by boat from the village of Orta San Giulio. It is almost entirely covered by a Romanesque basilica, a Benedictine convent and old houses, circled by a single quiet lane.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

Isola ComacinaIsola San Giulio
Gateway & travel timeAbout 5 min by boat taxi from Sala Comacina or Ossuccio (boat taxi)5 min by boat from Orta San Giulio (Lake Orta)
DaysA half-day trip is enoughA half-day or day trip is enough
Best monthsApr–Oct; May–Jun and Sep best; boats and the restaurant are seasonalApr–June and Sep–Oct; summer weekends busy
CarOn foot only; paths through the ruins take under an hourCar-free: walk the single lane around the island in 15 minutes
CostMid-range; the island lunch is a splurgeMid-range for the Italian lakes
BeachesNo beaches; swim from the rocks or from a boat in the bayNo beaches; swimming from lakeside lidos elsewhere on Lake Orta
Area7 ha—
PopulationUninhabited—
Highest point239 m—
Tours online121

Where they are

Tours and activities in Italy