Skip to content

Which one to choose in the United States

Alcatraz vs Angel Island

Two islands in the United States. Alcatraz has 42 tours to book; Angel Island has no tours listed. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Alcatraz

Alcatraz

United States

Alcatraz is a rocky islet of about 9 hectares in San Francisco Bay, two kilometres off the city waterfront, best known for the federal prison that held Al Capone from 1934 to 1963. Today it is a national park site with the cellhouse, a lighthouse, gardens and seabird colonies, reached by a 15-minute ferry.

Read the full guide →

Angel Island

Angel Island

United States

Angel Island is the largest natural island in San Francisco Bay, a hilly state park reached by ferry from San Francisco or Tiburon, with views over the Golden Gate and the city skyline. Once known as the Ellis Island of the West, it holds an immigration station where Chinese detainees carved poems into the walls.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

AlcatrazAngel Island
Gateway & travel time15 min by ferry from San Francisco (Pier 33, Alcatraz Landing)15 min by ferry from Tiburon or 30 min from San Francisco from San Francisco (Pier 41) / Tiburon
DaysHalf a day is enoughA day trip is enough
Best monthsAll year; Sep–Oct clearest and warmest; summer fog; book weeks aheadApr–Oct; Sep–Oct clearest views; fog in summer afternoons
CarOn foot only; a steep path climbs to the cellhouse, with a small shuttle for limited mobilityCar-free: walk, cycle or take the tram tour along the perimeter road
CostMid-range for San FranciscoMid-range; the ferry is the main cost
BeachesNo beaches; the shore is rock and cliff, and swimming in the cold bay currents is not allowedSmall sandy beaches at Quarry Beach and Perles Beach; cold water and no lifeguards
Area9 ha3.1 km²
PopulationUninhabited57 (2000)
Highest point41 m240 m (Mount Caroline Livermore)
Tours online42none listed

Where they are

Tours and activities in the United States