Skip to content

Which one to choose in Italy

Asinara vs Sardinia

Two islands in Italy. Asinara has 37 tours to book; Sardinia has 85 tours to book. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Asinara

Asinara

Italy

Asinara is an almost uninhabited island off the north-western tip of Sardinia, a national park of granite hills and empty coves that was closed to the public for more than a century as a prison and quarantine station. Today small groups visit by boat from Stintino or Porto Torres to see its white donkeys, old jails and clear water.

Read the full guide →

Sardinia

Sardinia

Italy

Sardinia is the second largest island in the Mediterranean, about 200 km west of the Italian mainland and just south of Corsica, with nearly 2,000 km of coast. It combines some of Europe's clearest water and whitest beaches with a wild mountain interior, thousands of Bronze Age stone towers and a language and cuisine of its own.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

AsinaraSardinia
Gateway & travel timeAbout 30 min by boat from Stintino from Stintino or Porto Torres (Sardinia)About 1 h by air from Rome or Milan; ferries 6 to 12 h from Olbia or Cagliari (airports); ferries from Genoa or Livorno
DaysA day trip is enoughA week or more
Best monthsMay–June and September; July–August hot; few boats in winterMay–June and September; Jul–Aug hot, crowded and costly; resorts close Nov–Mar
CarNo private cars: walk, hire a bike or e-bike, or join a minivan or 4x4 tourRent a car; trains and buses are slow and sparse beyond the main towns
CostMid-range; park access and transport bundled in toursMid-range for Italy; very expensive on the Costa Smeralda
BeachesSmall sandy coves such as Cala Sabina and Cala d'Oliva; some bays closed to protect wildlifeWhite sand and clear water: La Pelosa, Chia, Cala Goloritze, Costa Rei and Poetto
Area52 km²23,949 km²
Population11.6 million (2020)
Highest point408 m (Punta della Scomunica)1,834 m (Punta La Marmora)
Tours online3785

Where they are

Tours and activities in Italy