Skip to content

Which one to choose in Mexico

Holbox vs Isla Mujeres

Two islands in Mexico. Holbox has 95 tours to book; Isla Mujeres has 111 tours to book. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Holbox

Holbox

Mexico

Holbox is a narrow, car-free island about 42 km long off the north coast of the Yucatan Peninsula, separated from the mainland by a shallow lagoon full of flamingos and pelicans. Sand streets, golf carts, painted murals and whale sharks offshore in summer make it Mexico's quiet alternative to Cancun.

Read the full guide →

Isla Mujeres

Isla Mujeres

Mexico

Isla Mujeres is a narrow Caribbean island about 13 km off Cancun, only 7 km long and barely 650 metres across at its widest. It offers calm turquoise water at Playa Norte, a relaxed golf-cart pace, Maya ruins on the cliffs of Punta Sur and whale sharks offshore in summer, all 20 minutes from the mainland.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

HolboxIsla Mujeres
Gateway & travel time25 min by ferry; 3 to 3.5 h in total from Cancun from Chiquila (ferry); transfers from Cancun20 min by ferry, 30 to 45 min from the Hotel Zone from Cancun (Puerto Juarez)
Days3 to 5 nightsA day trip or 1 to 2 nights
Best monthsJun–Sep whale sharks, hot; Nov–Apr dry, windy; Sep–Oct stormyDec–Apr dry and breezy; Jun–Sep whale sharks but hot; hurricanes Jun–Nov
CarCar-free: walk, cycle or hire a golf cart; golf-cart taxis on sand streetsGolf carts, scooters and bikes for hire; taxis everywhere; the town is walkable
CostMid-range; pricier than the mainland, cash often neededMid-range, cheaper than the Cancun Hotel Zone
BeachesPale sand and shallow, greenish water; Punta Cocos and Punta Mosquito sandbarsFine white sand and shallow water at Playa Norte; rocky, wave-hit east coast unsafe to swim
Area56 km²4.2 km²
Population1,841 (2020)13,174 (2020)
Highest point1 m1 m
Tours online95111

Where they are

Tours and activities in Mexico