Skip to content

Which one to choose in South Africa

Robben Island vs Seal Island, False Bay

Two islands in South Africa. Robben Island has 90 tours to book; Seal Island, False Bay has no tours listed. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Robben Island

Robben Island

South Africa

Robben Island is a flat, windswept island of about 5 square kilometres in Table Bay, roughly 7 km off the Cape Town coast, where Nelson Mandela spent 18 years in prison. Now a museum and UNESCO World Heritage Site, it is visited on guided tours led partly by former political prisoners.

Read the full guide →

Seal Island, False Bay

Seal Island, False Bay

South Africa

Seal Island is a bare granite rock of about two hectares in False Bay, 5.7 km off the beaches south-east of Cape Town, packed with tens of thousands of Cape fur seals. It was once world-famous for great white sharks leaping clear of the water after seals; today visitors come by boat for the noise, the smell and the sheer scale of the colony.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

Robben IslandSeal Island, False Bay
Gateway & travel time30 to 45 min by ferry from Cape Town (V&A Waterfront, Nelson Mandela Gateway)Under 1 h by boat; Simon's Town is 45 min from Cape Town from Simon's Town / Cape Town (False Bay)
DaysA half-day tripA half-day trip is enough
Best monthsOct–Apr calmer seas; May–Sep crossings often cancelled by swellNov–Mar for warmer, calmer mornings; seals present all year
CarGuided bus tour plus a walk through the prison; no independent exploringNo landing: you see it from the boat; on shore use a car or a peninsula tour
CostMid-range; the museum ticket includes the ferryMid-range for Cape Town
BeachesNo beaches for visitors; penguins and seals on the rocky shoreNone on the island; swim at Boulders, Fish Hoek or Muizenberg on the shore of False Bay
Area5.1 km²2 ha
Population—Uninhabited
Highest point17 m5 m
Tours online90none listed

Where they are

Tours and activities in South Africa