Skip to content

Which one to choose in the United States

Sanibel vs Siesta Key

Two islands in the United States. Sanibel has 4 tours to book; Siesta Key has 10 tours to book. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Sanibel

Sanibel

United States

Sanibel is a low barrier island off Fort Myers on Florida's Gulf coast, reached by a causeway and famous for the seashells that pile up on its beaches. Strict building rules keep it free of high-rises, and more than half the island is protected wildlife land, including a large refuge for wading birds.

Read the full guide →

Siesta Key

Siesta Key

United States

Siesta Key is a barrier island on Florida's Gulf coast, joined to Sarasota by two bridges and known for its beach of fine white quartz sand that stays cool underfoot. About 13 km long, it mixes a lively beach village, condos and holiday homes with calm, shallow water that suits families.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

SanibelSiesta Key
Gateway & travel timeAbout 40 min by car from the airport from Fort Myers (Sanibel Causeway)10 to 15 min by car from downtown from Sarasota
Days3 to 5 nights3 to 5 nights
Best monthsDec–Apr dry and mild; hot, humid summers; hurricanes Jun–NovFeb–May dry, warm and busy; Jun–Nov hot, stormy and hurricane season
CarCar or bike; about 40 km of shared-use paths run along the main roadsFree trolley runs the length of the key; bikes work well; parking is tight
CostExpensive, even by Florida standardsMid-range for Florida, high in winter and spring
BeachesShell-strewn white sand on the Gulf side; Bowman's and Lighthouse Beach, Blind Pass for shellsSoft white quartz sand: Siesta Beach for families, Crescent Beach and Point of Rocks, Turtle Beach
Area—9 km²
Population—5,454 (2020)
Highest point—1 m
Tours online410

Where they are

Tours and activities in the United States