Skip to content

Which one to choose in Tuscan Archipelago

Elba vs Giannutri

Two islands in Tuscan Archipelago. Elba has 45 tours to book; Giannutri has 3 tours to book. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Elba

Elba

Tuscan Archipelago, Italy

Elba is the largest island of the Tuscan Archipelago and the third largest in Italy, lying only 10 km off the port of Piombino. It mixes granite mountains rising to 1,019 metres at Monte Capanne, more than a hundred beaches, old iron mines, hill villages and the houses where Napoleon spent his first exile.

Read the full guide →

Giannutri

Giannutri

Tuscan Archipelago, Italy

Giannutri is the southernmost island of the Tuscan Archipelago, a crescent of limestone just 2.6 square kilometres in size, about 18 km off Porto Ercole. It is car-free, almost uninhabited and protected by a national park, with clear water for snorkelling and diving, wild Mediterranean scrub and the ruins of a large Roman seaside villa.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

ElbaGiannutri
Gateway & travel timeAbout 1 h by ferry from PiombinoAbout 1 h by ferry from Porto Santo Stefano
Days3 to 5 nightsA day trip is enough
Best monthsMay–June and September; July–August crowded and expensiveJun–Sep when boats run; Aug busiest; Jun and Sep best for diving
CarA car or scooter is best; buses link the main towns, slowlyCar-free: walk the few paths from the landings; no buses or taxis
CostMid-range, high in AugustMid-range; bring food, as there is little to buy
BeachesSand at Marina di Campo, Fetovaia and Biodola; white pebbles at Sansone and Capo BiancoNo sand: two pebbly coves at Cala Spalmatoio and Cala Maestra, and swimming off the rocks
Area224 km²2.6 km²
Population31,36213
Highest point1,019 m (Monte Capanne)93 m (Poggio Capel Rosso)
Tours online453

Where they are

Tours and activities in Tuscan Archipelago