Skip to content

Which one to choose in San Juan Islands

Orcas Island vs San Juan Island

Two islands in San Juan Islands. Orcas Island has 3 tours to book; San Juan Island has 4 tours to book. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Orcas Island

Orcas Island

San Juan Islands, United States

Orcas Island is the largest of the San Juan Islands in north-west Washington, a horseshoe of forested hills, farms and quiet harbours reached by ferry from Anacortes. Mount Constitution, at 734 metres the highest point in the archipelago, rises from Moran State Park, and whale-watching boats leave from the island in summer.

Read the full guide →

San Juan Island

San Juan Island

San Juan Islands, United States

San Juan Island is the busiest of the San Juan Islands in northwest Washington, a rolling island of farms, forests and rocky shores where orcas are watched from land. It lies about an hour by ferry from Anacortes, with Friday Harbor as its only town and two historic camps from the Pig War.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

Orcas IslandSan Juan Island
Gateway & travel time1 to 1.5 h by ferry; 2 h drive Seattle–Anacortes from Anacortes (ferry); SeattleAbout 1 h direct by ferry, up to 2 h with stops from Anacortes (Washington State Ferries)
Days3 to 5 nights1 to 2 nights
Best monthsJun–Sep; whale watching May–Sep; ferries and rooms tight in Jul–AugJun–Sep for orcas and dry weather; Jul–Aug busiest
CarA car is the easy way: roads are hilly and long; bikes for fit ridersCar useful; bikes and mopeds for rent in Friday Harbor; seasonal shuttle buses
CostExpensive, even for the Seattle regionExpensive, even by Washington standards
BeachesPebble and gravel beaches with cold water: Crescent Beach, Obstruction Pass, North BeachRocky and pebbly shores; South Beach and the coves of the west side for walking, cold water
Area57 km²143 km²
Population—8,632 (2020)
Highest point734 m (Mount Constitution)329 m (Mount Dallas)
Tours online34

Where they are

Tours and activities in San Juan Islands