Skip to content

Which one to choose in Canada

Bonaventure Island vs Cape Breton Island

Two islands in Canada. Bonaventure Island has no tours listed; Cape Breton Island has 19 tours to book. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Bonaventure Island

Bonaventure Island

Canada

Bonaventure Island is a round, forested island of about 4 square kilometres, 3.5 km off the village of Percé at the tip of Quebec's Gaspé Peninsula. Its eastern cliffs hold one of the largest northern gannet colonies in the world, and together with Percé Rock it forms a national park reached by boat in summer.

Read the full guide →

Cape Breton Island

Cape Breton Island

Canada

Cape Breton Island is the rugged north-eastern end of Nova Scotia, joined to the mainland by a causeway and crowned by highlands that drop in cliffs to the Gulf of St Lawrence. It is known for the Cabot Trail, one of North America's great coastal drives, for Celtic fiddle music, Acadian villages and a reconstructed French fortress at Louisbourg.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

Bonaventure IslandCape Breton Island
Gateway & travel timeUnder 1 h by boat, with the loop round Percé Rock from Percé (park boats)About 3 h by car from Halifax to the causeway from Halifax (by road) or Sydney (airport)
DaysA day trip is enough3 to 5 nights
Best monthsJun–Sep for the gannet colony; boats run only from late spring to early autumnJul–Oct; late Sep to mid-Oct for autumn colours
CarCar-free: walk the trails; the colony is about 45 minutes on foot from the wharfA car is essential; there is little public transport outside Sydney
CostMid-range for Quebec; boat ticket plus park entryMid-range for Canada
BeachesNo swimming beaches; pebble shores and cliffs, and very cold water all summerSandy beaches at Inverness and Ingonish; cool water, warmer on the Gulf side in August
Area4.2 km²10,311 km²
PopulationUninhabited134,850 (2021)
Highest point—535 m (White Hill)
Tours onlinenone listed19

Where they are

Tours and activities in Canada