Skip to content

Which one to choose in Hawaiian Islands

Big Island (Hawaii) vs Maui

Two islands in Hawaiian Islands. Big Island (Hawaii) has 149 tours to book; Maui has 241 tours to book. The table and the two notes below put them side by side; the full pages have how to get there, what to see and when to go for each.

Big Island (Hawaii)

Big Island (Hawaii)

Hawaiian Islands, United States

The Big Island, officially Hawaii Island, is the youngest and largest of the Hawaiian Islands, at 10,430 square kilometres bigger than all the others combined. It has active Kilauea, snow on Mauna Kea at 4,207 metres, black and green sand beaches, manta rays at night and climates from desert to rainforest.

Read the full guide →

Maui

Maui

Hawaiian Islands, United States

Maui is the second-largest of the Hawaiian Islands, two volcanoes joined by a low isthmus in the middle of the Pacific. Haleakala rises to 3,055 metres above a dormant summit crater, and below it lie long golden beaches, the winding road to Hana and some of the best snorkelling and winter whale watching in Hawaii.

Read the full guide →

Side by side

Big Island (Hawaii)Maui
Gateway & travel time45 min by air from Honolulu; 5 to 6 h from California from Kona (Kailua-Kona) or Hilo airports5 to 6 h from California, 40 min from Honolulu from Kahului airport
DaysA week or moreA week
Best monthsApr–May and Sep–Oct; Dec–Apr for whales; warm year-round, east side wetApr–May and Sep–Nov for value; Dec–Apr for whales; Jun–Aug and holidays busiest
CarRent a car; the island takes 6 to 8 h to drive around and buses are sparseRent a car; buses are limited and taxis expensive
CostExpensive, though slightly cheaper than MauiVery expensive, even by Hawaiian standards
BeachesFewer than you expect: Hapuna and Kua Bay for white sand, Punaluu for black sand and turtlesLong golden sand at Kaanapali, Wailea and Makena; red and black sand on the Hana coast
Area10,434 km²1,883 km²
Population200,629 (2020)144,444 (2010)
Highest point4,207 m (Mauna Kea)3,055 m (Haleakala)
Tours online149241

Where they are

Tours and activities in Hawaiian Islands