Start with the flight
For a first trip, the easiest island is the one you can reach on a direct flight with a short transfer. From North America the choice is wide: Grand Cayman is about 1 hour 15 minutes from Miami, Aruba has direct flights from the US East Coast and Canada, and Puerto Rico has flights into San Juan from across the US, Canada, Europe and Latin America. From Britain, Barbados, Jamaica, Grenada and Grand Cayman have direct flights from London; from France, Martinique and Guadeloupe are about eight and a half hours from Paris; from the Netherlands, Aruba, Curaçao and Bonaire are reached directly from Amsterdam.
For Mexico, fly to Cancun: Isla Mujeres is 20 minutes away by passenger ferry from Puerto Juarez, and Cozumel 45 minutes by ferry from Playa del Carmen, so both work as a first taste or an add-on to the mainland. Dominica, by contrast, needs a connection via Antigua, Barbados, San Juan or Miami, or a fast ferry from Guadeloupe or Martinique.
Weather and hurricane season
The dry season, roughly December to April, is the high season almost everywhere, with the most sun and the highest prices from Christmas to Easter. Hurricane season runs from June to November, with the greatest risk and the heaviest rain from about August to October; storms are not daily events, but they can close airports and cancel boats, so travel insurance matters and flexible bookings help.
The exceptions are Aruba, Curaçao and Bonaire, which lie off Venezuela, outside the main hurricane belt. They are dry and sunny almost all year, with short showers from about October to December, which makes them the safest choice for a summer or autumn trip.
Beaches and easy swimming
If the trip is about calm sand and easy swimming, Aruba is the simplest choice: long white beaches on a sheltered coast, polished hotels and almost no weather risk, at a high price. Grand Cayman has Seven Mile Beach and calm, clear water, and Barbados has easy beaches, good food, rum and turtles on an English-speaking island. Isla Mujeres offers shallow swimming beaches and a small-town evening away from the bustle of the Cancun Hotel Zone.
Diving, snorkelling and hiking
Divers and snorkellers are spoilt for choice. Bonaire is built around shore diving, with flamingos and a relaxed, quiet feel; Curaçao adds small coves and colourful Willemstad; Cozumel has some of the best wall diving in the region; and Roatán, reached by direct flights from the US or the ferry from La Ceiba, offers affordable reef diving. Grand Cayman is known for the sandbar trips to Stingray City.
For mountains and rainforest, choose Saint Lucia, with its hikes, sulphur springs and the Pitons, or Dominica, the wildest of all, with waterfalls, hot springs, the Boiling Lake trail and whale watching. Martinique and Guadeloupe combine volcano hikes with beaches and French food, and Grenada adds rainforest walks, chocolate and rum to good beaches.
Cost and all-inclusive
Aruba, Barbados, Saint Lucia and Grand Cayman are expensive even by Caribbean standards. Curaçao is cheaper than Aruba, and Grenada, Dominica, Jamaica, Puerto Rico, Cozumel and Roatán are mid-range, while Martinique and Guadeloupe have prices close to mainland France and use the euro. All-inclusive resorts are common in Jamaica, Saint Lucia and Aruba and remove most decisions, though drinks and imported goods outside them cost more. Independent travel suits Puerto Rico, Curaçao, Martinique and Guadeloupe, where you rent a car and eat out.
Getting around
Most islands reward a rental car, but Barbados, Saint Lucia, Grand Cayman and Jamaica drive on the left, and Grenada and Dominica require a local driving permit. Barbados has cheap buses and shared vans along the coasts, Grenada numbered minibuses from St. George's, and Aruba buses along the hotel coast. In Jamaica, coaches and route taxis link the towns, though a car or a driver helps; use licensed transport and ask your hotel about areas to avoid. On Isla Mujeres people get around by golf cart, scooter or bike.
Where to book
Aruba: a week or more at any time of year, with hotels and flights booked months ahead for mid-December to April. Barbados: a week or more between December and April, with hotels and flights months ahead and a catamaran trip a few days before. Grand Cayman: a week, with hotels booked months ahead for winter and the Stingray City boat a few days ahead. Saint Lucia: a week or more in the dry season, with resorts months ahead and a guide for the Piton climb a few days ahead.
Bonaire: a week for divers, with the rental car or pickup booked as early as the room, since there is almost no public transport. Isla Mujeres: one or two nights from Cancun, with whale shark trips for June to September booked well ahead and the ferry bought on the day. Puerto Rico: a week between December and April, with a car for outside the capital and the island ferries and bio bay tours a few days ahead.